Created:
Updated:
The Ethics of Faked Live Music Performances
Details
Community judgment of the ethics of a "faked" (mimed to pre‑recorded) live performance depends on the axis of authenticity valued by that genre community.
Genre value axes:
- Jazz: real-time collaborative spontaneity / improvisation. Miming removes the communicative uncertainty that makes the performance meaningful.
- Hip‑hop: lyrical “realness” and contextual truth of the performer’s words. Faking undercuts credibility if the live delivery is staged or deceptively enhanced.
- Rock / Metal: athletic technical execution—visible evidence of disciplined effort and physical skill. Miming to a perfect track erases the proof-of-work the community celebrates.
Personal reflection:
I identify with the metal community; my motivation is to demonstrate skill achieved with my own hands and minimal external assistance. When I used miming (second take of a Tool cover). Ethical tension = convenience vs. core value of authentic exertion.
Core idea:
Ethical evaluation of faked live performance is community-relative: it harms the performance precisely where it hides the value-generating dimension.
Supporting Content
Back Matter
Source
References
- see::
- Censuring
Terms
Target
Tasks
Questions